
Just days after I floated the idea of the Lakers trading Andrew Bynum to the Denver Nuggets for Carmelo Anthony in my column about the Lakers’ trade possibilities, a Bynum-Melo rumor was actually reported by ESPN. The report states that the Nuggets and Lakers have had initial conversations regarding a swap that would revolve around Carmelo and Bynum but that no deal has been put into place at this moment. For all of those of you that think this deal would be beneficial for the Lakers, lets set things straight: Carmelo Anthony would be a horrible fit for the Lakers.
First, lets take a look at what I said in my column about Bynum:
This scenario is the least likely of all of these, but its the one that most casual fans are calling for. Carmelo Anthony has been linked to a number of teams this season and with the Lakers’ fans in panic mode and their GM talking about trades, it seems logical to throw out a “Carmelo to the Lakers” idea. This deal could be a simple two-for-two swap, star for star and bad contract for bad contract. Carmelo and Al Harrington for Bynum and Artest. The Nuggets get themselves a new player to center their franchise around and create on of the best big men duo’s in the league in Bynum and Nene.
This doesn’t make quite as much sense for the Lakers, though. Carmelo is a high volume scorer that needs 20 shots to score 25 points on most nights, which makes him similar to Kobe in a way. That’s not what the Lakers need. They don’t need another volume scorer that gets his points by doing the same things (mostly mid-range jumpers). Iguodala is a great fit because he would be willing to change his role to defensive stopper, transition highlight reel and occasional spot-up shooter. Anthony would likely only create problems for the Lakers, who are being criticized already for relying on Bryant isolations too often instead of triangle-based offensive sets. Thus, adding Anthony, who has been involved in 393 isolation plays this season, the second most in the league (behind Amare and in front of Kobe), would be a bad fit for the Lakers offense.
While Melo to the Lakers is a big story and though Lala might enjoy her new digs in Los Angeles, this trade doesn’t make sense for the Lakers, and the Nuggets may be able to get a little more than just Bynum elsewhere.
Digging in deeper to the numbers, Carmelo Anthony takes the most mid-range jumpers per game in the league (6.5 per contest) than any other player in the league, which means he is taking the worst shots possible more frequently than anyone else. Anthony takes almost all of those shots off the dribble, which is another problem. For a player like Dirk Nowizki, taking 6.1 16-23 foot shots per game isn’t a problem not only because he’s the best mid-range shooter perhaps ever, but also because 80% of his makes come off of an assist. Only 40% of Anthony’s long two point jumpers are the result of a pass, making his shot selection even more questionable.
More on why Carmelo would be a bad fit for the Lakers after the break…
Continue reading…